DSS 2026 / Day 2 / Amber Hall
Follow the Collateral: A Mental Model for Auditing Polymarket V2
Paul Clemson
Source: YouTube automatic caption track · Exported 2026-11-16. Timestamps link to the source video. Cue end times were not supplied.
Transcript
0:00Thank you.
0:01Hello, everyone.
0:03Uh, who in the room is a security
0:05researcher?
0:07That's a good number of hands. How many
0:10of you have looked at Polymarket V2?
0:14No hands. No, one hand.
0:15Okay. So cool. I think as someone at
0:20Quantstamp who one of a few companies
0:23that have been looking at Polymarket a
0:26lot over the past year,
0:28I think it's really cool and I think
0:30it's a really under explored area of
0:34crypto, D DeFi kind of.
0:37And I think more people should take a
0:38look. So what I want to do in the next
0:41seven minutes apparently is give you
0:44guys a bit of a a run through of a
0:47mental model that you can go away with
0:50and hunt that huge Polymarket bug
0:52bounty. So let's go.
0:57Oh, it worked. Okay, that's the first
0:59slide. Okay, so the base of Polymarket
1:03is a simple yes and no market.
1:06[clears throat] So for example, will my
1:08talk actually finish in five minutes?
1:11They've given me seven, which makes me
1:14think there is insider trading at play.
1:17So I think they might have manipulated
1:19this market. But yeah, essentially
1:22every Polymarket
1:24condition should always add up to the
1:27sum of the collateral. So if you put $1
1:30in, you get 100 yes and 100 no.
1:33And this always has to hold. This is the
1:36key thing I want you guys to take away.
1:39Oh.
1:41Did Donald Trump moment, sorry.
1:42[laughter]
1:43What I want you to take away is this has
1:46to always hold.
1:47Whatever they add, every new module,
1:49every bridge, every upgrade, if there's
1:52any way that you can get more than $1
1:55for a $1 worth of both yes and no,
1:58then there's trouble.
2:01Okay, so yeah, there is three very core,
2:03just kind of speed on this, three very
2:05cool actions you can do. Split is $1 in,
2:09100 yes, 100 no.
2:11Merge is the opposite of that. I've got
2:13100 yes and 100 no. I can get $1 back.
2:16And then redeem is obviously after the
2:19Oracle
2:21confirms Pulse Talk did indeed last
2:23longer than 5 minutes.
2:25If you're holding no, you can redeem for
2:27$1. If you're holding yes, then you
2:30lost, so
2:32GG.
2:35And then
2:36to go a little bit further, there's also
2:38neg risk markets. [snorts] Neg risk
2:40markets are essentially
2:44a group of markets where only one of
2:46them can be true.
2:47So for example, what color will my
2:49t-shirt be?
2:52Unless I'm wearing two t-shirts or I do
2:55like a Lady Gaga costume change, there's
2:58going to be one answer to this question.
3:00And today the answer is black.
3:02About 15 minutes ago it was white, but
3:04we won't get into that right now.
3:07But yeah, so this is another layer of
3:09complexity
3:11where
3:12the invariant changes a little bit and
3:14instead of yes plus no equals $1, the
3:18sum of all yes, blue, black, red, I know
3:23colors, well done me,
3:25all must equal $1.
3:27And then as of Polymarket V2, there's
3:30also an other position and this is
3:33essentially if
3:35I didn't turn up to the talk,
3:38kind of evacuate emergency,
3:41the event didn't happen, so cancelled
3:43essentially.
3:47And then
3:49the Oracle, another big source, the
3:51Oracle always has to report
3:54a legitimate result that sums to a
3:56dollar. So if they change Uma or Uma
3:59updates how they handle the results
4:03always has to stay with this core
4:06invariant of like
4:08one.
4:14And then as a V2
4:16you can there are markets that are not
4:19going to resolve anytime in the near
4:21future that exist on the Polymarket V1.
4:25For example, the 2028
4:27American presidential election, this
4:29market already exists. If they want to
4:32take this market over to Polymarket V2
4:35to get all the benefits of the cool new
4:37stuff they've added
4:39they need to map the existing market
4:41over to V2
4:43or have a split of the liquidity which
4:46is not cool. So yeah, and when they
4:50suddenly have presidential market on V1,
4:54presidential market on V2, you can
4:56imagine here
4:58even more ways that
5:01yes plus no
5:03if somehow yes
5:06person A
5:08uh could be true on the legacy V1 and
5:12person B is true on the new Polymarket
5:16V2
5:17suddenly yes plus no or yes plus yes
5:21is more than $1 and you can quite
5:24quickly
5:26drain lots of money and we don't want
5:28that to happen.
5:30So yeah, just as a
5:32kind of sum it up, if you guys want to
5:34take a look, these are a few of the key
5:36questions I think you should keep in
5:38your mind when you're planning things.
5:41When you are minting tokens or whether
5:44you're redeeming tokens, is there any
5:46way this can happen twice? For example,
5:48in the legacy
5:49to uh V2 migration I spoke about, is
5:53there any way I can claim on both? That
5:55would be terrible.
5:57And another one would be
5:59can I have
6:02the market of what color t-shirt Paul is
6:05wearing, black.
6:06Can the condition idea of that somehow
6:09collide with
6:12who wins
6:14the football tomorrow, whatever game?
6:16If that's the case, then
6:18again,
6:20how do you resolve the same question
6:22twice to the same condition
6:24problems?
6:25And then finally,
6:27similar to the migration question,
6:30is there any way that yeah, the Oracle
6:34on V1 and the Oracle on V2 can come to a
6:37different conclusion?
6:39Cuz if that happens, we got problems. So
6:41yeah, if you want to take a look at
6:43Polymarket, I would definitely
6:44recommend. It's very cool, and they're
6:46doing some fun stuff. And I've finished
6:49under 7 minutes,
6:51but not under 5. So
6:54I hope you guys lost a lot of money.
6:56Okay, thank you.
Source and accuracy details
- Names, organizations, technical terms, code and numbers may be misrecognized.
- Source wording and disfluencies are preserved; no editorial corrections were applied.
- Export contains whole-second cue starts only; cue ends and subsecond timing are unavailable.
- A full caption-track export does not establish that every spoken word is represented.
- Automatic YouTube captions; not human-verified against the audio.
Source export SHA256: 6681743e30e9d103fc7a8448094235c717c12837d6a73b1532be187e6d2aecb7