DSS 2026 — 2017 Parity Multi-Sig Hacks: A Behind the Scenes Retrospective Hudson Jameson Source video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=txGoVFg3SAE Automatic captions — not human-reviewed. Complete spoken-audio coverage is unverified. Source language tag: en (English). Source export SHA256: 184888cb511f0bae0f1e08bb6a104cb4e7273e1d051d9e6d62c108b3042ce603 [0:02] Hi everybody. I'm Hudson. [0:05] And this is the 2017 Parity Multi-Sig [0:07] Hacks talk. [0:09] You'll notice I said hacks for a reason [0:11] if you weren't there at the time. So, um [0:14] I've been around crypto for a while. Uh [0:17] from 2016 to 2021 I was at the EF doing [0:19] protocol coordination, security, DevOps, [0:22] and EIP stuff. So, um I ran some war [0:25] rooms and this was one of the most [0:27] interesting war rooms I ever ran, which [0:29] is why I brought it here today. I also [0:31] worked for Polygon Labs for a bit and [0:33] now I am head of Web3 at CertiK, which [0:36] is a cybersecurity company. [0:40] All right. [0:41] So, [0:42] it's July 19th, 2017. ETH is $223 [0:47] per coin. Don't you wish you could go [0:49] back in time? [0:50] Uh proof of work is still running [0:52] Ethereum. It's not proof of stake yet. [0:55] Um and we only have four clients that [0:57] are syncing to mainnet. So, now we have, [1:00] you know, all these proof of stake [1:01] clients and consensus clients and [1:03] execution clients. We just had four [1:04] clients at the time. So, it was a much [1:06] simpler time is what I'm trying to say. [1:09] Um I was at the IC3 Ethereum boot camp [1:12] with uh Vitalik and a bunch of people [1:15] from the Ethereum Foundation, Chainlink [1:17] Labs, and some other places. [1:19] Um [1:20] they this was um [1:23] a boot camp that still goes on every [1:24] year. You can look it up and uh it kind [1:27] of combines people in the industry with [1:30] people in the grassroots crypto movement [1:33] uh to uh come and uh build hackathon [1:37] projects basically. So, it's kind of [1:38] like a week-long hackathon get-together [1:41] type situation and uh we went to those [1:43] for a number of years and it was a lot [1:45] of fun. So, this is where I was on that [1:47] day. [1:50] I get a call from Skype from this [1:51] friendly fellow, Griff Green. Uh Griff [1:53] is uh one of the people who are is now [1:57] responsible for the DAO Security Fund, [1:59] uh but he used to be responsible for the [2:01] DAO itself. So, uh, I get a call from [2:04] Griff on Skype, and it says the [2:07] foundation multisig is being drained. [2:10] And I, uh, am just like in shock and I [2:14] hang up the phone and I absolutely [2:17] panic. Um, Cornell University, um, [2:21] I I [2:22] just has these long hallways and they [2:24] took my feet that day. I sprinted all [2:27] around. I would just go room to room and [2:28] say, where's Vitalik? Where's Vitalik? [2:30] The multisig is getting drained, but [2:32] which is some people. I wouldn't say [2:33] that's everybody who was in every room, [2:34] but I was, uh, just freaking out. So, [2:37] definitely not a good, um, first step on [2:39] my part as a security person to be [2:41] freaking out during this moment, uh, but [2:43] I was, uh, cuz I thought that, uh, you [2:46] know, I was working at the Ethereum [2:47] Foundation. That was where my paycheck [2:49] came from. [2:51] But luckily, um, I came back and I got a [2:55] call again from Griff and it turns out [2:56] it wasn't the foundation multisig that [2:58] was being drained. It was, uh, every [3:00] single parity multisig wallet that was [3:04] on live on mainnet was susceptible to [3:06] being drained. [3:08] So, parity is a, uh, company that now [3:13] does a lot of stuff with Polkadot, but [3:14] back at the time, uh, they made one of [3:16] the alternative Ethereum clients written [3:19] in Rust, uh, called parity Ethereum. And [3:22] they also did some consumer tech which [3:24] included a smart wallet, one of the [3:27] earlier smart wallets, um, [3:29] and uh, [3:31] that wallet had a constructor logic that [3:34] was, uh, extracted into a separate [3:35] library. So, this causes all public [3:38] functions from the library to be [3:39] callable by anyone including the init [3:42] wallet function which can change the [3:44] contracts owners and then delegate call [3:46] was used as a catch-all mechanism for [3:48] for fording all those, uh, commands to [3:51] the wallet. So, if you made a parity [3:53] multisig wallet, you were making a copy [3:56] of a library that they made and there [3:59] was an init wallet function that was [4:01] just uninitialized. So, anyone could go [4:03] in there and change what like change uh [4:08] uh who the owner was of the wallet and [4:10] how many [4:11] people had to sign off for the multisig [4:13] transaction. So as as the black hat, all [4:16] you had to do was call in that wallet [4:18] and change it to a one of one with their [4:20] address as the owner and then execute a [4:22] transaction to steal the funds from the [4:24] multisig, which is what's what started [4:25] happening. [4:27] So this is one of the first signs that [4:30] we got. Um this is Skype um [4:33] uh screenshots. Thanks Taylor Monahan or [4:36] Tay on Twitter uh for providing these. [4:39] She keeps everything apparently from [4:41] these attacks and I'm really happy about [4:43] that. [4:44] Um so Burned who was um responsible for [4:48] Swarm City, one of an early Ethereum um [4:51] consumer project said I don't want to [4:54] panic but our multisig looks like it got [4:55] hacked. And my favorite part is Harry [4:58] said what's your POA? [5:00] And Burned said what's a POA? A plan of [5:02] action. Panic. [5:04] So I wasn't the only one panicking. [5:06] There was also other people panicking at [5:07] the time. [5:10] So here's the participants. Online we [5:12] have My Ether Wallet crew which would be [5:14] like Taylor Monahan and her people. Uh [5:17] some people like Barry White Hat who are [5:19] still anonymous mostly to this day who [5:21] help out with these kind of situations. [5:23] Um we have Jordy Belinea uh and Griff [5:26] Green. At Cornell we have the Ethereum [5:28] Foundation and IC3 um who are there [5:31] helping. And then in the mountains we [5:34] have Parity. Parity was on a retreat [5:37] with their entire company in the [5:38] mountains while this was happening. We [5:41] could not get a hold of them for the [5:42] first half hour as a black hat was going [5:45] through and hand picking wallets to [5:46] drain. [5:49] So it's war room time. [5:51] Um [5:53] we're all in there and we're like [5:55] working together to get on a Skype uh [5:58] you know text message group and a Google [5:59] voice call and I'm leading that and [6:02] we're trying to get um a list of all [6:05] affected wallets so that we could want a [6:07] white hat attack and basically uh drain [6:10] all the wallets before the black hat [6:12] could get to them. [6:13] And Gavin Wood, who is the co-founder of [6:16] Ethereum and also uh was a part of [6:20] was the founder of Parity, put out a [6:22] security alert without telling us on [6:24] their Gitter channel, which Gitter is [6:27] like the Telegram of the time, [6:29] um and said that the that there's a [6:32] critical vulnerability. So then that got [6:34] put on [6:38] that got put on. [6:40] Next slide. [6:44] That got put on Twitter by Whale Panda. [6:46] So I'm in the room with like Ethereum [6:48] Foundation people and it's like uh [6:51] oh crap, Whale Panda just posted it. [6:53] Everyone's going to know about this now. [6:54] So then we started seeing other white [6:56] hats come online and start draining the [6:58] the the the uh wallets as well. [7:04] Next slide. [7:10] So we get to work. Uh Lorenz and Phil [7:13] Daian. So Lorenz is at Chainlink Labs, [7:15] but was also is a part of IC3 and then [7:17] Phil Daian, who is from Flashbots and a [7:20] bunch of other famous work, [7:21] uh make a script and a repo to store the [7:24] affected multisig addresses. They share [7:27] that with Jordi Ballina, who creates a [7:28] rescue script while Taylor Monahan and [7:31] the MyEther people communicate with uh [7:33] affected projects and monitor the [7:34] situation. [7:36] Uh many other unsung heroes that day [7:38] helping coordinate and make sure not [7:39] everyone is freaking out. [7:42] Next slide. [7:44] So suddenly the rescue starts. Jordi [7:47] hits the button and it's a race. There's [7:49] a second white hat who's draining [7:50] wallets. There's us who's draining [7:52] wallets and there's a black hat who's [7:54] hand picking the biggest wallets and [7:56] draining those. [7:57] Um at the end of the day, the black hat [7:59] hacker stole $32 million from three of [8:02] the projects with the biggest [8:03] treasuries. Unfortunately, Aeternity, uh [8:06] Edgeless and Swarm City. The main White [8:09] Hat Attack, uh, [8:10] uh, rescued 80.45 million in ETH and [8:14] 84.43 [8:15] million in tokens. Smaller White Hat was [8:18] 1.3 million in ETH and 63,000 in tokens. [8:22] So, the a total amount rescued was $166 [8:25] million, [8:26] which was an incredible amount of money [8:28] at the time for Ethereum. I know we just [8:30] had the Binance thing happen, so like [8:32] that's like nothing, but this was really [8:34] big, believe me. [8:37] Meanwhile in Spain, okay, so the attack, [8:40] uh, or the rescue happens, we finish it, [8:43] and I get a call from Griffin Jordi and [8:45] they're very afraid and they're like, [8:47] can we turn this into a multi sig? Can [8:49] we like do something to, uh, make this [8:53] more collaborative because I have a [8:55] Ledger Nano with $166 million. [8:58] They're in an apartment in Spain and [9:00] Griff sleeps like leaned up against the [9:02] door that night with a baseball bat on [9:04] his shoulder. [9:05] Like you can't make this stuff up [9:07] because it's like if people found out [9:09] where they were, you could just go and [9:11] like steal that. [9:13] So, wild stuff. [9:16] Um, after this happened, uh, I was a [9:19] little stressed, so I went out for [9:20] drinks with some of the IC3 and EF [9:22] people and, uh, this is me texting [9:25] Taylor, uh, [9:27] after I had a few drinks. I thought it [9:29] was a funny screenshot they kept, so I [9:30] threw it in here. [9:32] Uh, this doesn't make any sense. Don't [9:33] try to make sense of it. I was not [9:35] anywhere near coherent. [9:40] But this wouldn't happen again, right? [9:43] So, this is the Taylor DevOps 199. [9:47] New parity multi sig library contract is [9:49] deployed in July, [9:51] um, and then had an un uninitialized [9:53] ownership. [9:55] The contract itself, like what they they [9:57] like put the contract out there and they [9:59] never did a knit owner again, but this [10:01] time it was for the master like library [10:03] for it. [10:04] So, someone named DevOps 199 who was [10:07] just going through and self-destructing [10:08] contracts found it [10:10] and, uh put a [10:12] pair a post that said I accidentally [10:14] killed it. [10:15] Um this is the chat in Gitter where they [10:18] were talking about. They were like, am I [10:20] going to get arrested for this? [10:23] What do you why did you kill the [10:24] transaction? I'm a newbie. I'm just [10:26] learning. [10:27] You're famous now. [10:30] I'm just sitting killing destroyed [10:32] random contracts. You can see my [10:33] history. Frowny face. [10:36] So not the smartest tool not the [10:38] sharpest tool in the shed, but um still [10:42] to this day uh we look back on this as a [10:45] really really really funny set of [10:47] circumstances. [10:49] Um on the downside it did uh lock $90 [10:53] million worth of tokens and ether. [10:56] Um so that wasn't good at all. Um that [10:59] was mostly from Parity Foundation um or [11:02] the or the Web3 Foundation, I think. It [11:04] was one of the two had most of their [11:06] like treasury stuck in there. [11:09] Um some attempts were made to get [11:10] consensus to unlock it with a hard fork [11:13] um including EIP 999. Uh shout out to [11:16] anyone who remembers EIP 999 and all [11:18] that stuff. [11:19] Um but yeah, the funds are locked to [11:21] this day. You can still go in and see [11:22] that they're never going to be able to [11:23] be released. They're still just caught [11:26] in there. [11:27] So what are the lessons of this? I just [11:30] wanted to tell a really fun story, but [11:32] um the lessons are don't panic uh like I [11:35] did. For future war rooms, I did not [11:37] panic and did a lot better. Uh so I [11:40] grew. I learned. Um and find friends you [11:42] can make lifelong crazy memories with. [11:43] I'm still friends with many of the [11:44] people from that day and I'm seeing them [11:46] this Devcon and walk around and get to [11:48] see them. So yeah, just cherish the [11:51] people you meet. [11:52] Um I had time for like a question and [11:55] I'll repeat it back once when someone [11:56] asks if anyone has a question. [12:01] And if you don't, that's okay too. That [12:02] means I did a good job. [12:04] Thank you so much everyone.