DSS 2026 / Day 2 / Pearl Hall
The Missing Certification: What Web3 Can Gain from Standards
Suryansh Singh
Source: YouTube automatic caption track · Exported 2026-11-16. Timestamps link to the source video. Cue end times were not supplied.
Transcript
0:01Hello guys.
0:04I'm Suryansh Singh.
0:07I'm a security researcher at Open
0:09Zeppelin.
0:10I also go by 0x Monsoon on X. Maybe you
0:13know me by my pseudonym. And today I'm
0:16going to see
0:17I'm today I'm going to speak about
0:20standards, how they work in different
0:22industries,
0:23what kind of standards we need in Web
0:25three and how they can help us.
0:31So
0:33let's first start with what a standard
0:35is
0:36and why a standard is needed
0:38in let's say any industry.
0:41So
0:43a standard in my opinion can be you know
0:46defined in three ways like it has three
0:48jobs.
0:49First, it sets a floor for something.
0:54Like
0:56for a security standard, it would set a
0:58certain floor
1:00about what security measures your
1:02project or your software
1:05or your processes need to have to
1:07qualify.
1:08Secondly,
1:10a lot of industries
1:13are very technical
1:14and they may not make a lot of sense to
1:16people outside the industry. So for for
1:19someone who works in software like the
1:21aviation industry doesn't make a lot of
1:23sense to me and it would be vice versa.
1:26So it needs to send a signal
1:28about what it is actually certifying to
1:31people who are outside the industry.
1:34So it serves as a signal.
1:37Third,
1:38it also serves as a memory
1:40for what the industry has learned. So
1:43like every newcomer doesn't need to
1:45re-derive all the best practices and
1:48avoid all the pitfalls
1:50for things that other players in the
1:52space have already through trial and
1:54error found out.
1:58So
2:00that is a standard was. So, what
2:04is a good standard in my opinion?
2:07So, a good standard does not
2:11give qualities
2:14to the work that has been assessed. It
2:16wouldn't say, let's say a software is
2:18secure
2:19or it wouldn't say that
2:22an airplane
2:24can never go down.
2:26Right? So, it would like
2:28give you very specific claims and it
2:31would tell you like how it has been
2:33reached and how that has been assessed.
2:36It wouldn't claim that every the
2:38assessor has like assessed everything
2:40that is about the thing it's assessing
2:43and it would also give
2:47like when the assessment was done, for
2:49how long it is valid
2:51and it wouldn't
2:54try to claim like once anything has a
2:56certain certification that it's good for
2:58life.
3:00So,
3:01even in the tech industry, I
3:03I think like PCI DSS is a good security
3:06standard
3:07that a lot of you may be familiar with.
3:11So, if you're not, it's basically a
3:13standard for the payments industry that
3:15deals
3:16with payments using credit cards and
3:17debit cards.
3:19So,
3:20in that any merchant or any gateway that
3:25is processing payments using credit
3:27cards
3:28has a certain standard of checklist of
3:32processes
3:34of
3:35how it assesses vendors and how how it
3:38gives permissions to everyone in the
3:39company who can
3:41gain access access to user data
3:45and
3:48there's a certified assessor
3:51who'll come and who'll look at the
3:53complete system. They'll scope it out
3:56and
3:57see if
3:59the entire system meets those standards
4:03or those points or not
4:05and then it would give them a PCI DSS
4:07compliance certificate and which is
4:10valid for a certain number
4:13or certain amount of time.
4:16So let's discuss some certificates in
4:19detail in in other industries like I
4:20gave example of one. Let's go through
4:23two or three quickly and then I'll come
4:24to
4:26Web 3 and how
4:30standards can help in our industry.
4:33So
4:35when the jet
4:36engine age began in the 1940s and 50s
4:41there were almost like 40 fatal
4:43accidents per million flights.
4:47Right now the number is less than 0.05.
4:51So what happened was
4:54it
4:55was regulated by lawmakers that anytime
4:58something
5:00would fly
5:01before that it would need an air
5:03worthiness certificate from the
5:05regulator
5:06and
5:08in that there were a lot of best
5:10practices, things you cannot do, types
5:12of designs you can have. So all of those
5:14things were required and this
5:16certification is for a design.
5:19So you need to get the design approved
5:21then you can actually build it and then
5:23there'll there be another there'll be
5:26more tests.
5:28So this
5:31also serves as a really good
5:34example of what a memory is because
5:35every time something goes wrong in a
5:37flight there's a fatal or near fatal
5:39accident
5:41there's a big investigation that happens
5:44and all of this conclusions are actually
5:46added to the standard
5:49and then all the previous aircrafts that
5:51were certified needs to be recertified
5:54and any new aircraft would actually need
5:56to have the certification
5:58so that it's ensured that those same
6:00problems aren't
6:02in the other aircrafts.
6:07Um,
6:08during the age of maritime shipping that
6:11when it was booming in the 1500s, 1600s
6:14and so on.
6:16Um,
6:18at that point
6:20there was
6:21no quick communication systems.
6:24So anytime a voyage went whether it
6:28actually was successful
6:30you would only know when it came back.
6:33So it would take a few months, sometimes
6:35maybe even years to understand that. And
6:38there were
6:40companies and people who were invested
6:42investing in these voyages, a lot of
6:44lots of big sums of money.
6:46And they wanted to understand like what
6:48are we actually
6:51uh investing in.
6:53And to protect themselves they wanted
6:55insurance.
6:57But uh to get insurance the insurers
7:00needed to understand like how
7:03well built a ship is.
7:06So basically
7:07uh
7:08there was a society called a registered
7:09society and started it at a coffee house
7:11in London.
7:13And they started asking
7:17uh all of these
7:19uh like investors who wanted to get
7:21their voyages insured
7:23to get like hull certificates. So
7:26basically uh
7:27team of experts would come in, they
7:29would
7:30um go through
7:32the ship, check its hull, check its
7:33other things.
7:35And it would
7:37give them a certificate of how good it
7:39is. And on based of that the insurers
7:42would underwrite it and set the premiums
7:43and so on.
7:45So in this case there's no global
7:47regulator, there's no entity that would
7:49fine you.
7:50But here
7:52the forcing function was
7:54you need you needed to have a hull
7:56certificate to
7:58get
8:00insurance.
8:02And the example is FIPS 140 which is uh
8:06standard by the US government. Anytime
8:08the US government or any of its agencies
8:10want to buy
8:13any software that has a new
8:16encryption system,
8:19they basically have to go through
8:21through the standard.
8:23It takes a while to get certified
8:27and implementation is usually checked by
8:29experts and then it's also put on a
8:31public list for a year or two where
8:34anyone can break it.
8:36So basically here it's this
8:40certification is forced by the buyer
8:41because if we don't have it, the US
8:43government or its agencies cannot buy
8:45your software by law.
8:48So we we went through like three regimes
8:51and all of them were attesting different
8:54things for aviation was a design, for
8:55shipping it was a vessel,
8:57for crypto modules it's an
8:58implementation.
9:00You have different forcing functions.
9:02Sometimes it's insurers, sometimes it's
9:04regulators, sometimes it's buyers.
9:07So Web3 is also writing its flows.
9:10So we have a few nascent standards in
9:12Web3 already.
9:14So let's go through
9:16the ones we have and what the standards
9:18are for and then maybe we can discuss
9:21like
9:22what are the forcing functions that Web3
9:23has right now or can have in the future.
9:28[snorts] So let's first go through CCSS.
9:30It's a standard for custody basically.
9:33Think about any centralized exchanges,
9:35think about custodians, think about
9:39it can also also apply to self-custody.
9:42Think about there are a lot of digital
9:44asset trust fund trust
9:46funds that are listing on the exchanges
9:48now. They are they are custodying
9:50crypto. So it's it's for all of them.
9:53So it basically deals with how key
9:55material is generated, stored, accessed,
9:58used
10:00and who can actually
10:04like who are the people who have access
10:05to it, how like are their background
10:08background verified or not,
10:10do they undergo constant training or
10:12not, like what is the incident response
10:15framework that they have. So it's a it's
10:18a really big checklist and
10:21they have three levels. You could be
10:23certified at level one or two or three
10:26and the governing body is C four
10:29which maintains the standard and you
10:31need certified auditor, a certified CCSS
10:34auditor that can come and scope out your
10:36system and go through the checklist and
10:38gather evidence and if you pass all of
10:41them they can give you
10:44certificate from level one to three if
10:46you qualify otherwise you won't get one.
10:49So as I said there are three levels but
10:52you only qualify for the for the lowest
10:53level. So there are different aspects.
10:56So let's imagine if you qualified for
10:59level three in all but only level one in
11:03one of the aspects, the highest
11:05certificate level that you can you can
11:07get is level one
11:09then because in security and especially
11:12in custody your weakest link always gets
11:15you.
11:16So no matter how strong the other things
11:18are
11:19if you're lacking in one place that's
11:21probably
11:22the one that will get exploited.
11:26And it's supposed to be used in
11:28conjunction with other standards like
11:30you can also have ISO 27001 SOC two PCI
11:34DSS whatever you deal with like whatever
11:36applies to your system. If you also do
11:38any kind of custody then CCSS applies
11:41and you should probably get certified
11:43for it. There are other standards
11:46that you could probably use in
11:48instead of this. So
11:50like any CCSS certification would
11:52basically
11:54say like the system was assessed by a
11:57certified auditor
11:59and it would tell about like what were
12:01the various aspects that were met at
12:05what levels and what the scope of the
12:07system was
12:09and when it needs to be recertified.
12:12It would never claim whether there's
12:14contract logic that's correct because
12:16that's not in scope or the system is
12:19secure because that's not the point.
12:21The point is like enforcing a floor.
12:26The security alliance also publishes two
12:28different things. One is seal
12:30frameworks, the other is seal
12:31certifications. Seal frameworks is
12:33basically the memory
12:35where all the good practices
12:38and all the pitfalls are stored anytime
12:40time a hack happens,
12:42if anything could be added, learned and
12:44added from there, it would be added to
12:46the frameworks.
12:47You can read them, you can self-assess
12:49yourself. Seal certifications are where
12:52basically a certified auditor who
12:54understands the standards will come and
12:56look at your system
12:58and would assess it
13:00given like whatever thing
13:03you choose to be assessed by because
13:04even in
13:05the frameworks and certifications, they
13:07have a lot of sub modules.
13:10And this is point in time
13:12and usually your auditor will give you a
13:16recertification date if you're getting a
13:18seal certification.
13:20And you'll get a badge which can also
13:22checked on the blockchain using the
13:24Ethereum attestation service.
13:27So
13:28seal certifications have six modules.
13:31So you can choose to be assessed for one
13:34or multiple given which one supply to
13:37you or which signal do you want to give
13:39to let say
13:41to your stakeholders.
13:43There are so
13:45naming them one by one, there's multi
13:46seg ops, treasury ops, incident
13:48response, DevOps and infrastructure, DNS
13:51and registrar and identity and accounts.
13:54For any blockchain or web three project,
13:57multiple of these would apply but you
13:59don't need to get all of them at once.
14:01You can get yourself
14:04ready for one or two at a time
14:06and self-assess yourself and if you
14:10find that you're ready, you can get them
14:11one by one
14:13and
14:16would trade the
14:17to your stakeholders about where you
14:19stand
14:21as far as security is concerned.
14:23Seal is also very similar to CCSS in
14:26that way that
14:28it would only the the signal only says
14:30like
14:32the system was
14:33assessed by a certified auditor
14:36and it will give you the scope and what
14:41modules were in were you assessed
14:42against. It will never say that you are
14:44secure or any code was audited or the
14:47evidence is public because it's not.
14:51So
14:53flows already exist in web three.
14:56We need [snorts] to understand like what
14:57forcing functions we have because right
15:00now we don't have any. No regulators
15:02asking us for certifications.
15:05Whenever like a DAT is listed on the
15:07stock market we aren't asked for any.
15:10Investors probably just only ask for
15:11smart contract audits.
15:13So we need a regime where people other
15:16than the assessed party and the assessor
15:18actually
15:20cares whether you have a standard or
15:22not.
15:23And
15:24that's it from my side and hopefully
15:27we'll have this kind of regime soon
15:29where when more awareness about
15:30standards grow.
15:32Thank you.
Source and accuracy details
- Names, organizations, technical terms, code and numbers may be misrecognized.
- Source wording and disfluencies are preserved; no editorial corrections were applied.
- Export contains whole-second cue starts only; cue ends and subsecond timing are unavailable.
- A full caption-track export does not establish that every spoken word is represented.
- Automatic YouTube captions; not human-verified against the audio.
Source export SHA256: 8f56dfb216bba869bcadbcec63c1fa5d1f330d82258c8ea958197301916aa7c1